Petey's Summertime Seafood
Seafood · Rye · $$$
The People's Score
Loading…
Think it deserves more? Less? Add your score.
What I reviewed
- Fries
- Cold Lobster Roll8.8
“One of the best lobster rolls in the area and worth every dollar.”
First trip to Petey's Summertime Seafood in Rye and it delivered. The $30 cold lobster roll had a perfect meat-to-mayo ratio, plenty of fresh lobster, thinly shredded lettuce, and a soft, lightly toasted brioche bun. The fries were crispy and hot too. Ryan called it one of the best lobster rolls he's had in the area and totally worth the price.
Must Try
🍽️ Cold lobster roll
Watch the review
Reviewed July 5, 2026 by Crazy Dreamers.
Comments
Join the conversation — sign in to comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
More spots like this
Ray's Seafood Restaurant
$$Seafood · Rye
A hot jumbo lobster roll loaded with claw meat and seriously crispy fries.
Read the review →
Rye Harbor Lobster Pound
$$Seafood / Lobster · Rye
Tiny lobster shack at Rye Harbor delivering claw-packed chowder and a killer hot lobster roll.
Read the review →
Newick's Lobster House
$$Seafood · Dover
Nostalgic Dover seafood spot with big, flavorful scallops. Ask for them extra crispy.
Read the review →
Al's Seafood
$$Seafood · North Hampton
Everything you want in a New England lobster roll — fresh claw and knuckle meat, solid all around.
Read the review →